Monday, September 3, 2018

Are you still obsessed with education?


In Grace Boggs’ article, “Education: The Great Obsession”, she argues the need for change in the public school system. The present education system is roughly two generations old, it's almost as if our society is afraid to change it because it “feels” like that has always been the way.  Originally, education was needed for worker children to gain basic skills to obtain a job, at the time, during the industrial revolution. Now, the idea of education or the way education is presented should change to avoid an unwanted possibility that schools are becoming “... babysitting institutions in which their children had been socially promoted year after year”. Generations later in the current education system, are our students being challenged? Are students being an active part of their own learning?

As educators, we should allow students to learn from their own experiences and as well as the experiences of others. Boggs states, “The experience of performance is necessary to learning. Only through doing things and evaluating what they have done can human beings learn the intrinsic relation between cause and effect,” I choose this quote because as human beings, no matter what race, age, or gender, we can learn through and from past experiences. I feel this should be a huge part of education. Hearing different stories. Everyone learns differently, so we share our learning.  Just as everyone experiences life differently, so why not share those experiences? It’s a skill our young learners should be able to express. Which reminded me of a quote from Adrienne Goss article, “A Simple, Revolutionary Idea”, “children need to know and understand their history and how it informs the work that they need to do in the future.”(62) Our students our the citizens of the future.

Essentially, we are teaching our students to be citizens of the world, citizens of our community and it starts in the classroom. In “Imagining futures: the public school and possibility” by Maxine Greene, “the creation of communities in classrooms may be one of the most difficult and yet the most essential undertakings in the schools of the future.” (273) We need to create communities of the current time, not communities of the past. Our past should be a part of creating those communities. Today, school can be seen as something you have to do. The obsession of knowledge is still present but how much of it is fueled by pure motivation? I think back to the new question Adrienne Goss would ask if she reworte her undergraduate social foundations position paper “What will make my students come alive?” I want my student to feel they have control in what they are learning. They may not know at first but I would like to be there and guide them to where they would succeed best. Discover what their passions will be, I want them to come alive.

After reading these articles I started thinking about the “American Dream” and how education is usually something that has to been done to succeed coming overseas or borders. As a product of immigrant parents, education is something I had to do because it was an opportunity given to me by my parents. I continued my education as a thank you to my parents but it was also something I wanted to continue to pursue. I was in control of my learning.
Here is Matt Beaudreau and his TedTalk “It's About to Get Uncomfortable: Education in America”. He talks about the “uncomfortable” ideas in the American education system and the idea of change and challenge. He says “...when you start to challenge tradition in education…people get upset.” One of the first pictures Beaudreau shows is a picture of students sitting in rows;  waiting for instructions, waiting to be told what to do and what to learn. He goes on to talk about students leading the way to what their learning looks like and on their schedule.

2 comments:

  1. "Standardization of people, and of learning, you guys, that's utterly useless."

    Matt Beaudreau's Ted Talk really emphasizes the need to treat learning as individualized and not standardized. He jokes that because he is 35, is he only speaking to the 35 year olds in the crowd? It makes sense. He challenges the idea of grade levels by age and reading time frames. He mentions how Einstein struggled to read up until the 3rd grade. He states that going against grade level time frames is what is going best in the untraditional schools. Personally, this type of school excites me and also makes me nervous at the same time. I see the benefits of the school experiences (in the community, solving problems, experimenting) but I also do worry, similarly to Logan Laplante's (Ted talk) school experience, how it impacts them socially. As a product of public school education, I always preached that I would put my future children into public school, because of the exposure and diversity it brought me. I fear that students who may attend this Sudbury school or a homeschooling environment like Logan did, could miss out on some of the best experiences and friendships that a diverse public school offers. I was fortunate enough to have these experiences but maybe the quality of my classroom education took a back seat. The kind of relationships I made throughout my schooling made me into the person I am today. I believe I would have definitely missed out on them if I hadn't gone to public school.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "People just get too comfortable to ask 'is there something better?'" This quote of Beaudreau's resonated with me while listening to his Ted Talk. I’ll admit that I’ve gotten comfortable in my job. I find myself using the same lessons I have been for years, even though many of them could be improved. When faced with the choice of staying after school for a few more hours to tweak an activity or just photocopying the worksheet I went with last year and heading home, I often choose the latter. A complete overhaul of the educational system we have in place today is not going to happen overnight, so I need to remind myself that I have to do my part to help bring out the “genius element” in each of my students. I’m hoping that the conversations we have in class will keep inspiring me to work towards creating purposeful and student centered learning in my classroom.

    ReplyDelete